Jerusalem's Doom—Persecution of Christians
During the Gospel for the Final Sunday after Pentecost, Christ warns that the persecution of the Church would be a sign of the chastisement of Jerusalem and the end of the world.
Jerusalem’s Doom—Part III
In this chapter, Fr Coleridge tells us…
What false charges were made against Christians in the Apostolic age
How Satan always uses whatever media and communications to harass men
How God has promised to protect us even so.
Over the final Sundays after Pentecost (the spare Sundays, transferred from after Epiphany), the Roman Liturgy presents us with a dual sense of dread and confidence.
On the Fourth Sunday after Epiphany, we see the Apostles battered by a terrible storm on the Sea of Galilee—which Our Lord alone can calm
On the Fifth Sunday after Epiphany, Our Lord’s Parable of the Wheat and the Cockle warns us that his faithful will have to live side by side with heretics and the wicked—until the harvest at the end of the world
On the Sixth Sunday after Epiphany, Our Lord’s parables of the Mustard Seed and the Leaven primarily deal with the state of the Church in this world, but St Matthew’s final comment points towards a terrible chastisement of the “Chosen People.”
On the final Sunday of Pentecost—the “24th Sunday” which is delayed, depending on when Easter fell that year—we see what this chastisement was to be.
What’s more, we see that the chastisement of Jerusalem and the Jews is a foreshadowing and a warning of what is to come for the whole world at the end of time.
And time seems to be very short now.
The Doom of Jerusalem
From
Passiontide—Part I
Fr Henry James Coleridge, 1889, Ch. XIII, pp 237-46
St. Matt. xxiv. 1-28; St. Mark xiii. 1-23; St. Luke xxi. 5-24;
Story of the Gospels, § 144.
Sung on the 24th and Last Sunday of Pentecost-tide
Particular clauses of the prediction
In the first place, it will be observed that the clause, ‘You shall be hated by all men for My name’s sake,’ seems to be repeated more than once, or at least, if not repeated, it is inserted by different Evangelists at different stages of the prediction. St. Matthew puts it at the very outset of that part of his prophecy which relates to the treatment of the disciples themselves.
St. Mark and St. Luke place it towards the end of the same portion, after the betrayal of one another by Christians, and brethren, and children, and also the murder of some.
Hatred of the world
It seems probable that the ‘hatred of all men’ is, in one sense, the inheritance of the Catholic Church, as our Lord predicted.
‘If the world hate you, know you that it hated Me before you. If you had been of the world, the world would love its own, but because you are not of the world, but I have chosen you out of the world, therefore the world hateth you.’1
The Church rebukes the principles of the world, denies its authority, exposes its impostures, and threatens it with judgment. The world must always, therefore, instinctively hate it.
Besides, the world is not merely an impostor and a liar, but one that knows its own lies to be lies, and its own impostures to be impostures.
It is also under the dominion of Satan, who hates the Church as he hated our Lord. All the instincts of the kingdom of Satan are against the Church, and as long as her children, and especially her rulers, are faithful to her, they fight against Satan and attack his kingdom.
This brings all the force of the hatred of the world not only upon the Church as such, but upon individual Christians who keep her laws and are faithful in their allegiance to her rights.
It is not astonishing that the more men come to resemble our Lord, and avow their obedience to the Church, the more they incur the world’s enmity, which may not always rage against them openly, but which is stung to the quick by their lives, which rebuke its maxims, and which are always felt to threaten them with the punishment they deserve, and, as we see, to threaten them in a manner which causes discomfort in their hearts.
The work of the Apostolic ministry includes the government of the Church, and the maintenance of unity and discipline, in particular, is almost certain, if loyally performed, to bring with it the hatred of men, because it implies the duty of reminding them of their obligations and insisting on their discharge. Thus the words of our Lord may have different senses in the different passages.
In the Apostolic age
Another remark to be made on this part of the prophecy is that St. Matthew omits the paragraph which conveys the injunction of the faithful not to premeditate when they have to answer before tribunals, and the like, because the Holy Ghost will put words into their mouth at such times.
For St. Matthew has already given this same precept, in substance, in an earlier part of his Gospel, in his account of our Lord’s charge to the Apostles before sending them forth to preach.2 This seems to be the reason why this Evangelist omits it here.
It is true that St. Luke inserts it both here and in another place,3 and that it is unusual in him to have to repeat what he has already said. But this part of St. Luke’s Gospel is not so crowded with details nor so much marked by compression of those details as the parallel chapters of St. Matthew.
Again, the promise to perseverance, ‘He that shall endure unto the end, he shall be saved,’ comes in two somewhat different connections in the respective Evangelists. St. Matthew puts it after the prediction of the decay of charity.
‘The charity of the many shall grow cold, but he that shall persevere unto the end, he shall be saved.’
St. Mark puts it after the prediction of the hatred of the world.
‘And you shall be hated by all men for My name’s sake; but he that shall endure unto the end, he shall be saved.’
The words may well have been spoken in both connections, and we learn from them what it is that we are to persevere in—the outward unity of the faith in the Catholic Church, and the observance of God’s law, in all those points especially which excite the anger of the world.
False charges against Christians
There can be little doubt historically, that this prediction of the hatred of the world was very remarkably fulfilled in the earlier ages, and even in the times before the destruction of Jerusalem. When St. Paul, on his arrival at Rome, called together the chiefs of the Jews, to explain his position to them, we are told that they said they had received no complaints against him from Judæa, but they said:
‘We desire to hear of thee what thou thinkest, for as concerning this sect’—the Christians—’we know that it is gainsaid everywhere.’4
Tacitus, speaking of the false charge made by Nero against the Christians,5 concerning the great fire at Rome, speaks of them in the strongest terms of reprobation, and of their religion as exitialis superstitio. The people were ready to believe of them any crime laid to their charge.
The passages in Suetonius and Pliny are well known.6 The works of the early apologists are full of the fact that the Christians were commonly charged with atheism, cannibalism, unnatural lusts, incest, and the like.
A modern writer of great learning says that ‘to cite the passages from the works of these apologists would be an endless task, as they occur almost in every page.’7
It must be enough here to speak of the causes which may probably be assigned for the prevalence of these calumnies, in which we shall follow in the main, though very briefly, the author whom we have just quoted.
But upon what were these accusations based?
And how does this relate to our present time?
The rest of this commentary is for members.
Here are the earlier parts:
Here’s why you should subscribe to The Father Coleridge Reader:
Coleridge provides solid explanations of the entirety of the Gospel
His work is full of doctrine and piety, and is highly credible
He gives a clear trajectory of the life of Christ, its drama and all its stages.
If more Catholics knew about works like Fr Coleridge’s, then other works based on dubious private revelations would be much less attractive.
But sourcing and curating the texts, cleaning up scans, and editing them for online reading is a labour of love, and takes a lot of time.
Will you lend us a hand and hit subscribe?
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Father Coleridge Reader to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.